Submit an Academic Petition or Appeal

Manage Appeals

Petition Type: New
ID: 12478
Submitted: December 3, 2024 at 2:08:31 PM
First Name: Adam
Last Name: Finkelstein
Pronoun: He/Him/His
Preferred Name: Adam
Student Number: 20233568
Degree Program: BSH
Plan: LISC
Level of Study: 4

Petition Categories

Petition Categories: Drop a course after the academic deadline, Request credit (CR) standing in a course or courses
Code: BCHM 315
Term: Fall
Year: 2023
Petition Category: Request credit (CR) standing in a course or courses
Instructor's Name: Robert L. Campbell
Section/Class Number: 2258
Code: BCHM 316
Term: Winter
Year: 2024
Petition Category: Drop a course after the academic deadline

Petition Letter

Petition Letter: Background:

I have struggled with anxiety and depression for most of my life. The COVID-19 pandemic exacerbated my condition, leading to a rapid deterioration in my mental health. Despite my efforts to manage my symptoms through therapy and self-care, the transition back to in-person learning in Kingston was overwhelming.
During my third year (2022-2023), my mental health significantly deteriorated, resulting in my decision to defer the year due to severe thoughts of self-harm and suicide. This period of deferral allowed me to seek additional therapy and improve my self-care practices, which I hoped would enable me to better manage my academic responsibilities upon my return.

Challenges in the Fall 2023 Semester:

When the fall semester of 2023 began, I felt prepared to handle the stress of a full course load. I understood there would be an adjustment period having been off of schooling for 8 months. I anticipated that I would be able to adjust, but I was unable to. I faced considerable difficulties, particularly in courses with high-stakes exams and individual assignments. I perform my best in group-oriented assignments, which provide a supportive structure for managing my workload. In contrast, BCHM315/316, which relied heavily on quizzes and exams, were particularly challenging and contributed to significant stress and anxiety.

My struggles were compounded by the heavy weight of exams in BCHM315/316, which triggered a severe mental health crisis. During the winter semester, I continued to struggle completing individual assignments on time, with many of them finished last minute or submitted incomplete. I eventually asked for an extension on an end of semester assignment for my PHGY 355 course, which ate into my exam study time. Because of my self-doubt, I felt very unprepared for BCHM 316 compared to my other classes, leading me to defer two of my exams.
Despite my attempt to mitigate the impact by pro-rating my final exam weight and defer it to later in the summer, I was unable to overcome the daunting number of the exam’s weight.

**Specific Incident**:

During the BCHM316 final exam, I encountered a particularly distressing situation. After I wrote my first deferred exam and before the BCHM 316 final’s start time, I experienced severe stress-induced symptoms that led to bowel issues, causing me to arrive late. Upon starting the exam, I experienced a mental block and was unable to concentrate effectively. This resulted in me finishing the exam early, with multiple questions left blank. I have a sick note that corroborates this incident and further details the impact of my mental health on my performance.
Steps Taken and Future Plans
Recognizing the critical nature of these challenges for my pursuit of a career in medicine, I have sought guidance from a performance coach and am implementing reframing exercises to better manage my self-doubt and stress. I am committed to applying these techniques to improve my academic performance and demonstrate my true capabilities.

Request for Consideration:

Given the severe impact of my mental health challenges on my academic performance, including the specific difficulties experienced during the BCHM316 final exam, I respectfully request a credit standing in BCHM 315 and to drop my BCHM 316 course after the academic deadline. I am dedicated to overcoming these obstacles by using the support systems I have made in and outside of school. QSAS has been an invaluable piece of my academics, and the student wellness services will continue to play a significant role in cultivating my mental health.
Thank you for considering my petition. I am willing to provide any additional documentation or information if needed, including the sick note related to the exam incident.

Documentation

Professional Letter Detail: NO DOC
Document: 2888_001.pdf
Document: VEC AF.pdf

Level 1 Status

Status: Partial Grant

Level 2

Appeal Type: Level 2
ID: 302
Submitted: January 10, 2025 at 11:19:45 AM
Relevant Petition: 12478
Decision(s) Being Appealed: Request credit (CR) standing in a course or courses: BCHM 315, Fall 2023 (Robert L. Campbell)

Appeal Grounds

Appeals to the Board of Studies must include a letter based on one or more of the Grounds for Appeal (Appeal Regulation 3.4). What are the grounds you are basing your appeal on?
  • The Associate Dean's decision did not follow the rules of procedural fairness. A breach of procedural fairness includes such things as the Associate Dean failed to:
    • Make a reasonable decision in your appeal. A “reasonable” decision is one that is based on evidence, thought out and supported by facts and logical inferences from the facts. To be reasonable, the decision must contain adequate reasons for the conclusions.
Appeal Grounds Details: I believe the decision to deny the credit standing was made prematurely. I was in correspondence with the Faculty of Arts and Science Petitions regarding an off-campus physician's note form. On December 13th I was told my petition would be sent to the Associate Dean on December 16th if they did not hear back from me. I replied to them on the 14th letting them know I would need to call my physician's office on that day to get it filled out, since they were closed on the weekend. I was told that I could forward the document once I had it. I was under the impression that the petition would be sent once I sent the document, but I received my decision on December 18th, and did not get the form until January 2nd.

Appeal Letter

Appeal Letter: I believe that my appeal for a credit standing in BCHM 315 was denied due to insufficient evidence from a third party to corroborate my experiences during the 2023 fall semester. It was confirmed by the Faculty of Arts and Science Petitions that I met the requirements to qualify, and they also recommended me to provide documentation by my health care provider to build my case.

During our correspondence, they provided me with an off-campus physician’s note form URL which I sent to my family doctor, who has worked with me for most of my life. Given that their office was very busy, they were not able to give me the completed form before the decision to deny the credit standing request was made.

I understand why the credit standing was denied, since the decision was likely made relying only on my perspective. Relying on my words alone would be insufficient to reasonably grant my request. However, I believe the physician’s note provides important third-party evidence to substantiate the negative impact of my mental health throughout my life, but also particularly during the 2023 fall semester.

Thank you for your time and I would greatly appreciate your consideration.

Documentation

I plan to submit additional documentation at a later date: An off-campus physician's note form will be submitted to ascbos@queensu.ca same-day (2025-01-10), as I was unable to upload the document to the website for an unknown technical difficulty.
Edit Appeal
Select a decision letter template to generate and queue a decision letter using its content.

History

Originally submitted December 3, 2024 at 2:08:31 PM.

FieldReferenceOld ValueNew ValueNoteUserDate/Time
statusN/AReceivedIncompleteKerri Andrews2024-12-05 10:52:38 AM
statusN/AIncompleteIn ReviewKerri Andrews2024-12-13 10:59:30 AM
statusN/AIn ReviewPartial Grant Kerri Andrews2024-12-18 1:57:15 PM
associate_deanN/AJenn Stephenson, Ph.D.Kerri Andrews2024-12-18 1:57:15 PM
decision_letterN/AN/ADecision letter sentKerri Andrews2024-12-18 1:58:01 PM
new_appeal_level_2N/ALevel 2Level 2 Appeal ID: 30220ajsf2025-01-10 11:19:45 AM
statusN/AReceivedGrantedNew documentation supported the ADA granting this appealLibby Hearn2025-01-13 10:04:54 AM