Submit an Academic Petition or Appeal

Manage Appeals

Petition Type: New
ID: 12726
Submitted: January 28, 2025 at 5:00:22 PM
First Name: Lillian
Last Name: Liddell
Pronoun: She/her
Preferred Name: Lilly
Student Number: 20396851
Degree Program: BA
Plan: PHIL
Level of Study: 2

Petition Categories

Petition Categories: Request to take more than 6.0 units of courses on a letter of permission through another institution

Petition Letter

Petition Letter: Lillian Liddell
January 28th, 2025
Petition Letter: LOP for the University of Victoria
Dear Associate Dean,

My name is Lillian Liddell, I am a second-year philosophy undergraduate student here at Queen’s.
I am writing a petition letter to request a Letter of Permission to take one full semester (15 credits) at the University of Victoria from September to December 2025 for family and mental health reasons.

I love Queen’s and have thoroughly enjoyed my time studying here thus far. Attending this prestigious institution has provided unparalleled education and opportunities for me, as well as allowed me to grow and learn amongst amazing peers and faculty. I am working to go to law school, and thus, I have already written my first LSAT (October 2025) and have worked extremely hard to maintain a high academic standing at Queen’s and put my all into every course and club I have been a part of.

Unfortunately, this year has been extremely difficult on my mental health due to my distance from family and some family medical issues that have recently become more urgent. Because of these unforeseen circumstances, I need to be able to live much closer to them in the near future. My Grandmother, who helped raise me and lives in Victoria, has had Dementia for a few years now, and it has been getting drastically worse lately. She is one of the most important people in my life, and before moving to Ontario, she helped raise me through my childhood, and I visited her frequently throughout my adolescence. Because of this, it is now urgent I live close to her and my other family in Victoria so I may spend as much time with her as I can while she can still remember who I am. These family issues, as well as the distance from my family and loved ones, have made this year extremely taxing on my mental health. While I have been able to maintain a high academic standing as I am a driven, resilient individual, I have realized I cannot continue to live and work this hard while all of this is going on.

I am planning on staying in Victoria close to family for the summer and am looking to get special permission to spend the first semester in Victoria next year. At The University of Victoria, I would take 3 Philosophy courses, two at the 300 level to fulfill my remaining six philosophy (option course) credit requirements, as well as one philosophy at the 200 level and two other upper-year elective Arts courses to fulfill nine elective credits, to best continue my rigorous Philosophy and Arts education. I have written out a complete academic plan, which is included in my petition documents, including the previous syllabuses for all the courses I hope to take. Further, I have emailed and gotten the support of the Philosophy Undergraduate Chair, Kerah Gordon-Solmon and attached a letter of support from my parents and personal therapist. If this petition is accepted, I plan to return to Queen’s for the remainder of my degree and hopefully law school, or else take time off after the first semester of 2025 if it becomes necessary at that time.

My academic progress and continuation of such is extremely important to me. As such, this plan would allow me to thrive close to family and loved ones in need while continuing my academic progress and rigorous education. I sincerely hope Queen’s can accommodate these circumstances so I may continue my progress and work towards my goals while I attend to family matters.

Thank you for your time and consideration,
Lillian Liddell


Academic Plan

Academic Plan: Lillian Liddell – Academic Plan – UVIC LOC 2025
I am currently enrolled as a full-time Student at Queen’s University, in my second year of a Bachelor of Arts degree. I currently hold a 4.0 overall GPA.

I am applying for a Letter of Permission to do a full-time semester (5 courses) at the University of Victoria from September to December of 2025 for personal mental health and family medical concerns (described in my petition letter).

Given my current GPA, I have not struggled with the academic demands of my program and have sufficient skills and work habits to continue to do so. Further, I maintain the financial capacity to study and live both at Queen’s and the University of Victoria (per the approval of this request).

See below an outline of the courses I am applying to take, their full information and syllabus, as well as justification explaining why these courses will better my overall education and learning while continuing to challenge me academically.

PHIL 339 – Theories of Justice
- Instructor: C. Macleod
- Description: An examination of problems in and approaches to contemporary political philosophy. Topics may include equality, freedom, structural injustice, the interrelationship between racial, gender, class and cultural oppression, injustices across borders and the coherence and cross-cultural justification of human rights
- Offered: Regularly in the Fall Term
- Syllabus: See Included PDF ‘PHIL339_Syllabus’
- Reason: Given my interest in Law and the use of my Philosophy degree as a Pre-Law, this course will provide important learning in the Philosophy behind Justice and the background of the Legal System in Canada. Given the Syllabus, this course provides rigorous philosophical instruction in a domain highly applicable to my future goals and interests, maintaining the quality of my current degree plan and aiding in my learning and progression as a student.

PHIL 333 - Philosophy and the Environment (Ecophilosophy, Subjectivity, and Ecotherapy)
- Instructor: C. Goto-Jones
- Description: A philosophical investigation of the moral and conceptual dimensions of environmental problems. Different philosophies of the relation between humans and nature will be compared.
- Offered: Regularly in the Fall Term
- Syllabus: See Included PDF ‘PHIL333_Syllabus’
- Reason: I am highly interested in environmental studies and am considering a career in Environmental Law. As such, this course would provide Philosophical education in highly relevant concepts on the relationship between the Environment and Philosophy, especially given Philosophy is the background for all Law. This is a domain of philosophy not currently offered at Queen’s and a topic I have not previously been able to study. Given the Syllabus, this course provides rigorous philosophical instruction in a domain highly applicable to my possible future interests so I may continue to delve deeper into understanding the various topics I am considering pursuing in my future and developing as a student.

PHIL 232 - Moral Problems of Contemporary Society
- Instructor: P. Dietsch and S. Woodcock
- Description: Philosophical introduction to a variety of controversial issues in contemporary society, focusing on understanding and critically assessing the practical ethical dimensions of such topics as abortion, euthanasia, the treatment of animals, violence and war, environmental protection, punishment, racism and free speech.
- Offered: Regularly in the Fall Term
- Syllabus: See Included PDF ‘PHIL232_Syllabus’
- Reason: This course provides a different perspective to what I have previously studied in moral philosophy. I have been highly interested in and enjoyed courses in general moral philosophy and the history of moral philosophy, yet I have not taken a course that bridges the gap between the background and understanding with its modern application. This course provides a broad education in various contemporary topics and how moral philosophy fits into it. Given the syllabus, this course would provide rigorous philosophical education in a domain I have not yet studied and a topic I am highly interested in to continue my philosophical education and broad understanding of moral philosophy.

SOCI 206 - Crime and Deviance
- Instructor: Michael Ma, Garry Gray, and Tayler Zavitz
- Description:
Course description
o In this course, we will set out to think seriously about what it means to study criminology in the current context.
o We will explore concepts, trends, theories, institutions and processes associated with defining, explaining, and responding to crime and deviance. We will consider the roots of contemporary ideas about deviance and social control, including our own beliefs and assumptions.
o By thinking critically about the status quo, we will develop an understanding of how things came to be --and how they might be changed. This course offers an opportunity to reflect on important social issues and critically consider some taken-for-granted beliefs about crime, law, justice, and social control.
Course outcomes/objectives
o Having successfully completed this course, you will be able to:
 explain how crime is a social phenomenon
 identify, describe, and critically analyze the various ways that crime is measured
 analyze the role of social and historical context in crime and criminalization
 apply various interdisciplinary theories to the study of crime and criminalization
 analyze the effects of media representation on criminological issues
 describe how Eurocentric perspectives might influence crime and criminalization
 critically assess opposing points of view on key criminological issues
 analyze the impact of colonization on Indigenous peoples in relation to the Canadian criminal justice system
- Topics may include:
o Right and wrong, fear of harm, causation, media, counting, consent, social response, racism, inequality and poverty.
- Offered: Regularly in the Fall Term
- Syllabus: See Included PDF ‘SOCI206_Syllabus’
- Reason: I have not had the opportunity to take any Sociology classes at Queen’s because I did not take Sociology 100 in my first year. I was originally enrolled in a Liberal Arts degree and took course requirements as such; then, the program was cut in my first year, however, because of the requirement for that degree, I never took the prerequisite for upper-year sociology courses. Sociology, while not my primary interest, is a broad area of study I am highly interested in and understand its importance in society. This course, with no required prerequisites, would offer me the opportunity to study a topic in sociology that is highly applicable to Law and interesting to me personally while adding important layers and depth to my Undergraduate education. Given the course description, this course will provide a rigorous sociology education that will add to my education and learning as a student.

PSYC260 - Introduction to Mental Health and Well-Being
- Instructor: Todd Kettner
- Description: Examines theory and research related to mental health and well-being in adulthood. Topics address various aspects of psychological distress (such as mood and anxiety disorders, personality disorders, substance use, and schizophrenia) and psychological well-being. Biological, learning, developmental, humanistic, and cross-cultural perspectives are used to understand the definitions and etiology of mental disorders and psychological well-being.
- Offered: Regularly in the Fall Term
- Syllabus: See Included PDF ‘PSYC260_Syllabus’
- Reason: While I am a Philosophy major, my other area of great interest throughout my university education has been psychology. PSYC 100 challenged me tremendously, yet I succeeded in achieving a high grade after learning to work and study hard in my first year. I am currently taking Cognitive Psychology in my second year, and while this topic interests me, I am more interested in Mental Health and abnormal psychology, as it influences why people may be driven to commit crimes or act in various abnormal ways, which, in turn, impacts how law is practiced, laws are made, and why individuals act in the ways they do. Further, courses in these topics aid me to better understand my own psychology and struggles with mental health so I may continue to better myself and learn to cope with life as I move through it. This course would provide rigorous learning and depth to my university education, enabling me to better approach the law as I progress in my goals, and better function as an individual in society, overall enabling me to be a better student and person.

Documentation

Professional Letter: Lilly L Letter of Support.docx
Documentation Detail: Letter of Support from Parents
Documentation Detail: PHIL232 Syllabus
Documentation Detail: PHIL 333 Syllabus
Documentation Detail: PHIL 339 Syllabus
Select a decision letter template to generate and queue a decision letter using its content.

History

Originally submitted January 28, 2025 at 5:00:22 PM.

FieldReferenceOld ValueNew ValueNoteUserDate/Time
statusN/AReceivedIn ReviewKerri Andrews2025-02-05 8:45:45 AM
statusN/AIn ReviewGrantedKerri Andrews2025-02-24 10:07:42 AM
associate_deanN/AJenn Stephenson, Ph.D.Kerri Andrews2025-02-24 10:07:42 AM
decision_letterN/AN/ADecision letter sentKerri Andrews2025-02-24 10:08:34 AM