Manage Appeals
Petition Type: New
ID: 14485
Submitted: June 15, 2026 at 10:38:41 PM
First Name: Angelique
Last Name: Hoffstead
Pronoun: She/Her/Hers
Preferred Name: Angelique
Student Number: 20546486
Email: 24yyw@queensu.ca
Degree Program: BAH
Plan: HLTH
Level of Study: 1
Petition Categories
Petition Categories: Waive the requirement to withdraw for one year
Petition Letter
Petition Letter: To Dr. Naaman, the Associate Dean (Academic),
I am writing to request consideration of my extenuating circumstances in relation to my academic standing.
On December 5, 2025, I suffered a severe concussion and was rushed to Kingston Health Sciences Centre (KGH). I have attached documentation confirming my emergency room visit, including my physician's information. Records of the CT scan that was performed are available upon request (they take 30 days to be retrieved and delivered). Additional medical documentation is also available upon request.
Following my diagnosis, I was instructed to follow standard concussion recovery protocols, including avoiding screens, bright lights, and loud environments. Unfortunately, my condition worsened over the following months. I experienced severe migraines, persistent nausea, constant balance issues, and insomnia, at times going more than three days without sleep.
When I returned to residence after winter break, even the normal noise levels in my dorm triggered severe symptoms. Attending classes became increasingly difficult because exposure to classroom lighting and noise often caused nausea and vomiting. As a result, my attendance and ability to participate academically declined significantly.
The prolonged effects of my concussion also had a substantial impact on my mental health. I developed severe depression and experienced a relapse of my eating disorder (Bulimia). The combination of my physical symptoms and declining mental health made it extremely difficult to manage my academic responsibilities.
In March, I sought help through Queen's Student Wellness Services. I have attached documentation of my appointment and the psychiatric evaluation form that was provided to me. While discussing my eating disorder and mental health challenges was extremely difficult, I recognized that I needed support and began reaching out to both healthcare professionals and trusted friends within my residence community.
By early April, my concussion symptoms began to improve, and I made every effort to prepare for my exams. However, by that point, the cumulative impact of missing assessments, reduced attendance, and months of struggling with significant medical and mental health challenges had already severely affected my academic performance.
Since then, I have taken substantial steps to ensure my future success. I have established a support network, found a therapist, and developed strategies to better manage challenges when they arise. I have also enrolled in summer courses as part of my plan to transition from Psychology to Health Studies, with the goal of pursuing a career focused on eating disorder awareness, advocacy, and treatment.
I am currently enrolled in Health 101, IDIS 199 in preparation for health studies, and two additional electives (EMPR 110 and MUSC171) . My current grade in Health 101 is 95%, and I have submitted all assignments on time. My summer academic performance reflects my current abilities and commitment to my education when my health is properly managed.
I respectfully ask the committee to consider that my academic difficulties were not the result of a lack of effort or commitment, but rather the result of a severe concussion, significant mental health challenges, and a relapse of a serious eating disorder. These circumstances affected nearly every aspect of my ability to function academically and physically during the year.
I am now in a much healthier position, have appropriate medical and mental health support in place, and have developed a clear plan for academic success moving forward. I am confident that I can succeed at Queen's University and demonstrate the level of academic performance that reflects my true capabilities
I am writing to request consideration of my extenuating circumstances in relation to my academic standing.
On December 5, 2025, I suffered a severe concussion and was rushed to Kingston Health Sciences Centre (KGH). I have attached documentation confirming my emergency room visit, including my physician's information. Records of the CT scan that was performed are available upon request (they take 30 days to be retrieved and delivered). Additional medical documentation is also available upon request.
Following my diagnosis, I was instructed to follow standard concussion recovery protocols, including avoiding screens, bright lights, and loud environments. Unfortunately, my condition worsened over the following months. I experienced severe migraines, persistent nausea, constant balance issues, and insomnia, at times going more than three days without sleep.
When I returned to residence after winter break, even the normal noise levels in my dorm triggered severe symptoms. Attending classes became increasingly difficult because exposure to classroom lighting and noise often caused nausea and vomiting. As a result, my attendance and ability to participate academically declined significantly.
The prolonged effects of my concussion also had a substantial impact on my mental health. I developed severe depression and experienced a relapse of my eating disorder (Bulimia). The combination of my physical symptoms and declining mental health made it extremely difficult to manage my academic responsibilities.
In March, I sought help through Queen's Student Wellness Services. I have attached documentation of my appointment and the psychiatric evaluation form that was provided to me. While discussing my eating disorder and mental health challenges was extremely difficult, I recognized that I needed support and began reaching out to both healthcare professionals and trusted friends within my residence community.
By early April, my concussion symptoms began to improve, and I made every effort to prepare for my exams. However, by that point, the cumulative impact of missing assessments, reduced attendance, and months of struggling with significant medical and mental health challenges had already severely affected my academic performance.
Since then, I have taken substantial steps to ensure my future success. I have established a support network, found a therapist, and developed strategies to better manage challenges when they arise. I have also enrolled in summer courses as part of my plan to transition from Psychology to Health Studies, with the goal of pursuing a career focused on eating disorder awareness, advocacy, and treatment.
I am currently enrolled in Health 101, IDIS 199 in preparation for health studies, and two additional electives (EMPR 110 and MUSC171) . My current grade in Health 101 is 95%, and I have submitted all assignments on time. My summer academic performance reflects my current abilities and commitment to my education when my health is properly managed.
I respectfully ask the committee to consider that my academic difficulties were not the result of a lack of effort or commitment, but rather the result of a severe concussion, significant mental health challenges, and a relapse of a serious eating disorder. These circumstances affected nearly every aspect of my ability to function academically and physically during the year.
I am now in a much healthier position, have appropriate medical and mental health support in place, and have developed a clear plan for academic success moving forward. I am confident that I can succeed at Queen's University and demonstrate the level of academic performance that reflects my true capabilities
Academic Plan
Academic Plan:
My academic goal is to complete a Bachelor of Arts (Honours) in Health Studies, instead of my initially planned Bachelor of Arts (Honours) in Psychology. Through my second recovery process, I have become even more aware of how eating disorders take over every aspect of your life and trap you in a cycle of shame and fear that prevents someone from seeking the help they deserve. As a result, I would like to use my degree to work toward health promotion, mental health advocacy, and eating disorder awareness. My long term goal is to pursue a career focused on improving access to health education about mental health disorders without stigma and supporting individuals affected by eating disorders.
To ensure my future academic success, I have developed a structured degree completion plan. As previously stated, I am currently enrolled in summer courses and am demonstrating strong academic performance, including a current grade of 95% in HLTH 101 with all assignments submitted on time, as mentioned previously. This performance reflects my current abilities and commitment to my education now that I have the appropriate support and resources in place.
This is my academic plan for successfully completing the remaining requirements of my Bachelor of Arts (Honours) in Health Studies.
Year 2 (2026-2027)
Fall Term:
• HLTH 102 – Personal Health and Wellness
• ANAT 100 – Anatomy of the Human Body
• PSYC 100 – Principles of Psychology (A)
• (Elective)
• (Elective)
Winter Term:
• HLTH 205 – Introduction to Health Promotion
• PSYC 100 – Principles of Psychology (Part B)
• (Elective)
• (Elective)
• (Elective)
Year 3 (2027-2028)
Fall Term:
• HLTH 252 – Introduction to Research Methods
• KNPE 251
• (Elective)
• (Elective)
• (Elective)
Winter Term:
• HLTH 305 – Fundamentals of Health Policy
• HLTH 315 – Theory and Practice of Health Behavior Change
• (Elective)
• (Elective)
• (Elective)
Academic Success Strategy:
In addition to my course plan, I have implemented several measures to support my continued academic success:
• Ongoing therapy and mental health support.
• Continued monitoring of my recovery from my concussion.
• Regular use of academic advising services.
• Early communication with instructors when challenges present themselves.
• Maintaining a structured study schedule and assignment calendar.
• Utilizing my support network of friends, family, and healthcare professionals.
• Prioritizing attendance, assignment completion, and consistent study habits.
I would like to respectfully request reinstatement and permission to return to my studies in the Fall term. My summer academic performance demonstrates that I have regained the ability to perform at a high level when supported by appropriate medical care and healthy coping strategies. I am committed to following this plan and am confident in my ability to successfully complete my degree and contribute positively to the Queen’s community.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Sincerely,
Angelique Hoffstead
20546486
My academic goal is to complete a Bachelor of Arts (Honours) in Health Studies, instead of my initially planned Bachelor of Arts (Honours) in Psychology. Through my second recovery process, I have become even more aware of how eating disorders take over every aspect of your life and trap you in a cycle of shame and fear that prevents someone from seeking the help they deserve. As a result, I would like to use my degree to work toward health promotion, mental health advocacy, and eating disorder awareness. My long term goal is to pursue a career focused on improving access to health education about mental health disorders without stigma and supporting individuals affected by eating disorders.
To ensure my future academic success, I have developed a structured degree completion plan. As previously stated, I am currently enrolled in summer courses and am demonstrating strong academic performance, including a current grade of 95% in HLTH 101 with all assignments submitted on time, as mentioned previously. This performance reflects my current abilities and commitment to my education now that I have the appropriate support and resources in place.
This is my academic plan for successfully completing the remaining requirements of my Bachelor of Arts (Honours) in Health Studies.
Year 2 (2026-2027)
Fall Term:
• HLTH 102 – Personal Health and Wellness
• ANAT 100 – Anatomy of the Human Body
• PSYC 100 – Principles of Psychology (A)
• (Elective)
• (Elective)
Winter Term:
• HLTH 205 – Introduction to Health Promotion
• PSYC 100 – Principles of Psychology (Part B)
• (Elective)
• (Elective)
• (Elective)
Year 3 (2027-2028)
Fall Term:
• HLTH 252 – Introduction to Research Methods
• KNPE 251
• (Elective)
• (Elective)
• (Elective)
Winter Term:
• HLTH 305 – Fundamentals of Health Policy
• HLTH 315 – Theory and Practice of Health Behavior Change
• (Elective)
• (Elective)
• (Elective)
Academic Success Strategy:
In addition to my course plan, I have implemented several measures to support my continued academic success:
• Ongoing therapy and mental health support.
• Continued monitoring of my recovery from my concussion.
• Regular use of academic advising services.
• Early communication with instructors when challenges present themselves.
• Maintaining a structured study schedule and assignment calendar.
• Utilizing my support network of friends, family, and healthcare professionals.
• Prioritizing attendance, assignment completion, and consistent study habits.
I would like to respectfully request reinstatement and permission to return to my studies in the Fall term. My summer academic performance demonstrates that I have regained the ability to perform at a high level when supported by appropriate medical care and healthy coping strategies. I am committed to following this plan and am confident in my ability to successfully complete my degree and contribute positively to the Queen’s community.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Sincerely,
Angelique Hoffstead
20546486
Documentation
Professional Letter: 724292575_1598718535310717_5836753022791550077_KGHRECORDS.png
Document: queens wellness.jpg
Documentation Detail: Mental Health Appointment Conf.
Document: Screenshot 2026-06-15 220612-1.png
Documentation Detail: HLTH 101 Current Grades
Documentation Detail: Psychiatry Referral Consultation Form Confidential
Decision Letters
Level 1 Status
Status: DeniedLevel 2
Appeal Type: Level 2
ID: 377
Submitted: July 17, 2026 at 10:31:47 PM
Relevant Petition: 14485
Decision(s) Being Appealed: Waive the requirement to withdraw for one year
Appeal Grounds
Appeals to the Board of Studies must include a letter based on one or more of the Grounds for Appeal (Appeal Regulation 3.4). What are the grounds you are basing your appeal on?
- The Associate Dean's decision did not follow the rules of procedural fairness. A breach of procedural fairness includes such things as the Associate Dean failed to:
- Make a reasonable decision in your appeal. A “reasonable” decision is one that is based on evidence, thought out and supported by facts and logical inferences from the facts. To be reasonable, the decision must contain adequate reasons for the conclusions.
Appeal Grounds Details: I am basing my appeal on the grounds that the initial decision did not fully account for the financial and systemic barriers that prevented me from managing my academic registration, meaning the conclusion that I
Appeal Letter
Appeal Letter: July 17, 2026
Angelique Hoffstead
20546486
24yyw@queensu.ca
Dear Members of the Board of Studies,
I am writing to formally appeal the decision rendered on July 3, 2026, by Associate Dean Naaman, which upheld the ruling that I be Required to Withdraw for One Year. The initial decision denied my petition on the basis that I failed to drop my Fall 2025 and Winter 2026 courses by the academic deadlines. I am submitting this Second Level appeal because the initial review did not fully account for the absolute financial, systemic, and physical barriers I faced, meaning the conclusion that I simply failed to manage my deadlines was missing critical context.
The primary reason I was unable to drop my courses within the required timeframes was an institutional lockout that was completely out of my control. I come from a first generation immigrant low-income family, and we experienced a financial crisis during the academic year that left my family unable to secure my tuition payments on time. Consequently, Queen's University placed an administrative financial hold on my SOLUS account, which completely locked my account functions. I was procedurally and electronically barred by the university itself from dropping, adding, or altering any part of my course registration. Because of these financial constraints, I was unable to access SOLUS, which was a key resource required to adjust my registration until my family was finally able to secure the necessary funds to clear the balance and lift the hold at the end of the academic year.
Dealing with this financial stress on top of everything else only made my health situation worse. Following an emergency room admission at KGH on December 5, 2025, for a severe concussion, I was placed on a strict clinical protocol to avoid all screens and computers. Because Queen's relies entirely on online portals, I was medically restricted from using any electronics at risk of making my concussion worse. The trauma of the concussion also triggered severe depression and a critical relapse of Bulimia Nervosa, which I noted in my first appeal. The physiological toll of this illness, paired with severe neurological insomnia where I routinely went up to three days without sleep, left me in a complete survival crisis. My executive functioning and memory were so shattered by the physical trauma and nutrient depletion, I was in a state of depression I thought I would never recover from. Per Regulation 1.7.1.8, my current enrollment in two summer courses (IDIS 199 and HLTH 101) serves as real-time proof that these temporary financial and medical extenuating circumstances have been fully resolved. Now that our financial situation has stabilized and my health has recovered, my academic capability has returned. A decision focusing solely on deadlines does not capture the reality of a low income student facing a total administrative lockout while fighting a traumatic brain injury and a severe health relapse.
I respectfully request that the Board of Studies evaluate the reality of these barriers, waive the requirement to withdraw, and permit me to continue my studies this Fall. Upon my return, I intend to register for a lighter and reduced course load to allow myself to earn my education at a pace that works for me and sets me up for long term success.
Thank you very much for your time, empathy, and consideration of my appeal.
Sincerely,
Angelique Hoffstead
Student ID: 20546486
Angelique Hoffstead
20546486
24yyw@queensu.ca
Dear Members of the Board of Studies,
I am writing to formally appeal the decision rendered on July 3, 2026, by Associate Dean Naaman, which upheld the ruling that I be Required to Withdraw for One Year. The initial decision denied my petition on the basis that I failed to drop my Fall 2025 and Winter 2026 courses by the academic deadlines. I am submitting this Second Level appeal because the initial review did not fully account for the absolute financial, systemic, and physical barriers I faced, meaning the conclusion that I simply failed to manage my deadlines was missing critical context.
The primary reason I was unable to drop my courses within the required timeframes was an institutional lockout that was completely out of my control. I come from a first generation immigrant low-income family, and we experienced a financial crisis during the academic year that left my family unable to secure my tuition payments on time. Consequently, Queen's University placed an administrative financial hold on my SOLUS account, which completely locked my account functions. I was procedurally and electronically barred by the university itself from dropping, adding, or altering any part of my course registration. Because of these financial constraints, I was unable to access SOLUS, which was a key resource required to adjust my registration until my family was finally able to secure the necessary funds to clear the balance and lift the hold at the end of the academic year.
Dealing with this financial stress on top of everything else only made my health situation worse. Following an emergency room admission at KGH on December 5, 2025, for a severe concussion, I was placed on a strict clinical protocol to avoid all screens and computers. Because Queen's relies entirely on online portals, I was medically restricted from using any electronics at risk of making my concussion worse. The trauma of the concussion also triggered severe depression and a critical relapse of Bulimia Nervosa, which I noted in my first appeal. The physiological toll of this illness, paired with severe neurological insomnia where I routinely went up to three days without sleep, left me in a complete survival crisis. My executive functioning and memory were so shattered by the physical trauma and nutrient depletion, I was in a state of depression I thought I would never recover from. Per Regulation 1.7.1.8, my current enrollment in two summer courses (IDIS 199 and HLTH 101) serves as real-time proof that these temporary financial and medical extenuating circumstances have been fully resolved. Now that our financial situation has stabilized and my health has recovered, my academic capability has returned. A decision focusing solely on deadlines does not capture the reality of a low income student facing a total administrative lockout while fighting a traumatic brain injury and a severe health relapse.
I respectfully request that the Board of Studies evaluate the reality of these barriers, waive the requirement to withdraw, and permit me to continue my studies this Fall. Upon my return, I intend to register for a lighter and reduced course load to allow myself to earn my education at a pace that works for me and sets me up for long term success.
Thank you very much for your time, empathy, and consideration of my appeal.
Sincerely,
Angelique Hoffstead
Student ID: 20546486
Documentation
Document: Screenshot 2026-07-17 221947.png
Document: Screenshot 2026-07-17 223004.png
History
Originally submitted June 15, 2026 at 10:38:41 PM.
| Field | Reference | Old Value | New Value | Note | User | Date/Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| status | N/A | Received | Incomplete | Kerri Andrews | 2026-06-22 9:33:33 AM | |
| status | N/A | Incomplete | In Review | Kerri Andrews | 2026-06-27 7:28:39 PM | |
| status | N/A | In Review | Denied | Kerri Andrews | 2026-07-03 3:49:20 PM | |
| associate_dean | N/A | Dorit Naaman (Associate Dean Academic) | Kerri Andrews | 2026-07-03 3:49:20 PM | ||
| decision_letter | N/A | N/A | Decision letter sent | Kerri Andrews | 2026-07-03 3:50:23 PM | |
| new_appeal_level_2 | N/A | Level 2 | Level 2 Appeal ID: 377 | 24yyw | 2026-07-17 10:31:47 PM | |
| status | N/A | Received | In Review | Kathrine Scott | 2026-07-24 3:24:09 PM |

