Submit an Academic Petition or Appeal

Manage Appeals

Petition Type: New
ID: 9412
Submitted: July 20, 2022 at 3:50:12 PM
First Name: Jack
Last Name: Hodgins
Student Number: 20307952
Degree Program: BAH
Plan: ECON
Level of Study: 1

Petition Categories

Petition Categories: Waive the 21-day or one term deadline

Petition Letter

Petition Letter: I am appealing to waive the 21 day deadline in order to appeal my requirement to withdraw for one year. Upon attempting to select Autumn courses, I was met with a block, informing me that I was required to withdraw. I called an academic advisor, and was told that I would have missed an email, sent in May, detailing this. Around the time of the email being sent, I was under the impression, as instructed by a PASS advisor, that I was in no danger of this happening and so was not at all on the lookout for any emails like this. I also was the only support for my girlfriend who was going through a major depressive episode (evidence in the form of a doctors note can be included if necessary to speak to the severity of the situation), and so I hyper focused my academic mind to my summer courses so as to not let my grades slip, and therefore was not being diligent with my inbox.
The reason my grades were as they were last year is becasue I myself went through a major depressive episode- it started near the beginning of first year and my family live in the UK so I had very limited support. But, I pulled myself out of it and came up with a plan. This plan started with talking to an academic advisor to see what could be done and how to move forward. I specifially checked to ensure whether all attempted units/courses would count towards the 24 unit threshold to be able to come back undeclared, and was assured that only passed/completed units/courses would go towards it. (Evidence of this assurance is included in supporting documentation). On this basis, I then moved forward with renting a house and booked flights for travel to and from home up till christmas. I then arranged to complete summer courses (which have now put me over the threshold) and to spend most of my summer in Kingston so I could start my turnaround largely distraction free as few students would remain here over summer. I have created good momentum for myself and am making good progress, as shown by the summer courses I am passing where I wasn't passing before. Withdrawal for a year would be a huge hardship for me, and it would be detrimental to the progress and momentum I have started to build.

Documentation

Professional Letter: Jack Letter of Support.pdf

Level 1 Status

Status: Denied

Level 2

Appeal Type: Level 2
ID: 92
Submitted: August 19, 2022 at 3:09:32 PM
Relevant Petition: 9412
Decision(s) Being Appealed: Waive the 21-day or one term deadline

Appeal Letter

Appeal Letter: Members of the Board of Studies,
I am appealing the Associate Dean's decision to deny my appeal to waive the 21-day appeal deadline. I will respond to each point highlighted in the email from Dr Stephenson.
Firstly, my extenuating circumstance was most certainly a significant psychological event that was beyond my control and had a huge effect on my ability to work. I couldn't concentrate on anything else in my life, including reading emails. I was the sole support and caretaker for my girlfriend who was in the midst of a long term depressive and manic episode. Please note, within the past week (as of 19th August 2022) she has been diagnosed with Bipolar disorder which I hope better speaks to the severity and length of the situation (please see supporting document). Despite my attempts to involve my girlfriend's family to help, they were very unsupportive, which meant that I had to completely focus my time on her. What little time and mental capacity I had left went to making sure I passed my summer courses.
Furthermore, this should demonstrate that this wasn't only the month of May that I was facing these challenges for; I remained her sole caretaker until July, when her family finally took over. My original supporting documentation only included May, as that is what I had requested for it to say; I only thought the month of May was relevant as that is when the email was sent to me detailing my requirement to withdraw.
Additionally, the conversations that I had with PASS are certainly relevant, as I will now explain.
I myself was very depressed in the first semester and into the second semester and therefore was not doing any of my work. My family lives in the UK, so I had no family support, nor any social support as I had just moved country to go to Queens for first year. I was very alone, lying in bed all day and only getting up once to eat and then going back to bed. I also had no Doctor, as I had just recently moved and was not in any particular state of mind to figure out the medical system in a new country. I therefore don't have any documentation to back this up, although if you can access my lunch card's records they will corroborate my story- I have also included a testament from my mother regarding my mental well being. That said, it was my girlfriend's mental health that contributed to my missing of the email; my mental health is only relevant for context so I hope that the absence of a doctor's note for myself is not detrimental.
I finally managed to pull myself out of that depression mid second semester, and I knew I needed to come up with a plan to put myself back on track. I started by calling PASS on the 15th March 2022, and had a conversation with them whereby I was told about a 24 unit threshold, which, if I was under, meant that I could return to Queens in September as an undeclared student. I wasn't sure if this meant attempted or passed units, and so I arranged another meeting with PASS on the 6th April 2022 and asked on the call if that meant 24 passed units, or 24 attempted units, and I was told that they weren't sure so would check with a higher up. I was later told that in relation to my question, if I failed a course I would not receive the credits for it. I did not feel this was clear enough as to whether it meant receiving the credits in general, or in relation to the threshold. Hence, I asked again the next day on the 7th April 2022 in the zoom text chat for absolute clarity (which I have provided), and I was assured that the threshold was for 24 units, and if I failed a course I would not receive the units for it (evidence provided). I was at no point informed about a requirement to withdraw, and therefore had absolutely no idea that I should look at the academic calendar to find information about it. I had no reason to question what the Academic advisors had told me.
I was also at no point informed of the 18 unit threshold that appears on the email detailing my requirement to withdraw, so I made no attempt to drop any more courses to match this, as I was planning on redoing the courses I failed to remove them from my transcript. Based on the information I received, I elected to stay in Kingston for most of summer, despite my housemates leaving. This was so I could take two summer courses, to jump start myself getting back on track. I was assured by PASS that I was nowhere near the threshold, and therefore that it would be absolutely fine to take these courses, and also to come back in September 2022.
I had spoken to PASS on three separate occasions, and on no occasion was I given any information about a requirement to withdraw. Instead, it was confirmed that I could take summer courses without going over the threshold. We also discussed whether I should take 1-3 summer courses, and PASS advised me to take 1-2 due to workload.
Therefore I was not expecting to look out for an email, apart from those about my courses. The information I received from PASS is absolutely relevant: it was on the basis of their advice that I chose to do the summer courses which have now put me above the 24 unit threshold. I would also like to stress how beneficial it will be if I am allowed to continue this positive trajectory that I have started - I have managed to turn myself around despite all the aforementioned difficulties, and I would very much like to continue down this road.

Documentation

Documentation Detail: No additional documentation other then the three included here.
Select a decision letter template to generate and queue a decision letter using its content.

History

Originally submitted July 20, 2022 at 3:50:12 PM.

FieldReferenceOld ValueNew ValueNoteUserDate/Time
statusN/AReceivedIn ReviewSpring Forsberg2022-07-21 10:03:17 AM
statusN/AIn ReviewIncompleteSpring Forsberg2022-07-21 10:31:25 AM
statusN/AIncompleteIn ReviewSpring Forsberg2022-07-28 3:52:05 PM
statusN/AIn ReviewDeniedSpring Forsberg2022-08-15 8:47:24 AM
associate_deanN/AJenn Stephenson, Ph.D.Spring Forsberg2022-08-15 8:47:24 AM
decision_letterN/AN/ADecision letter sentSpring Forsberg2022-08-15 8:47:55 AM
new_appeal_level_2N/ALevel 2Level 2 Appeal ID: 9221JWH22022-08-19 3:09:32 PM
statusN/AReceivedGrantedPamela Briand2022-08-31 8:23:48 AM
decision_letterN/AN/ADecision letter sentPamela Briand2022-08-31 8:25:55 AM
decision_letterN/AN/ADecision letter sentPamela Briand2022-08-31 8:25:55 AM